Superhero Ethics

Matthew and Riki, along with returning guest Abby, dive deep into Section 31, Star Trek's controversial covert intelligence organization. The discussion explores the ethical implications of having a secretive, unaccountable agency within Starfleet and examines the recent Section 31 movie starring Michelle Yeoh.How does Section 31 challenge Star Trek's utopian vision? The hosts examine the tension between Gene Roddenberry's optimistic future and the pragmatic needs of maintaining galactic peace. They question whether having a CIA-like organization contradicts the Federation's principles of transparency and democracy, drawing parallels to real-world intelligence agencies.Is Starfleet truly just an exploratory organization, or is it fundamentally military—or even colonialist—in nature?The conversation delves into how Section 31's existence reveals deeper truths about Starfleet's dual role as both a diplomatic and military force, challenging the narrative that Starfleet is purely focused on peaceful exploration.W